Most of today’s UK-EU agreement will destroy wealth in the UK economy

Most of today’s UK-EU agreement will destroy wealth in the UK economy

Growth Commission Chairman Shanker Singham has issued the following response to the deal agreed by Prime Minister Andy Burnham in Brussels today:

“We commend the UK and EU on reaching an agreement on the mutual recognition of professional qualifications for architects. This is precisely the type of agreement which will generate economic growth.

“However, the rest of what has been announced, in particular the Sanitary and Phytosanitary agreement, the Emissions Trading Scheme agreement and the two cooperation agreements on digital and competition, will destroy wealth in the UK economy. By the government’s own estimation, the benefits for GB to EU/NI trade are only 0.05% of GDP to 2040.

“Set against this, our Growth Commission estimates of the cost of a loss on opportunity for better agrifood regulation and the likely negative reaction of our non-EU trading partners amounts to over 3% GDP per capita in the long run. Even if our estimates are ten times too large, this would still be a negative deal for the UK.

“Cooperating with the EU on a digital and competition regime that has done such damage to the EU’s own economy – which in the words of Dirk Auer of ICLE in Brussels has turned the EU into an ‘open air museum’ – will damage the UK’s tech sector, which has been one of the few bright spots of the UK economy in recent years.”

In Resetting The UK’s Relationship With The EU: An Economic Analysis Of The Options, the Growth Commission Paper published on Monday, we considered the likely impact of various scenarios, including the new agrifood deal involving dynamic alignment of Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) regulations whereby the UK signs up to EU rules and standards now and in the future. We found that while this will cut red tape for British food, animal and plant exports to the bloc, it will gravely limit the current freedom to import from the rest of the world at competitive prices without quotas and to innovate through technologies such as gene editing. The Growth Commission concluded that the savings achieved through less red tape for UK exporters (noting that only six per cent of UK food production goes abroad) will be dwarfed by higher prices, meaning that the country will be around £74 billion worse off over the coming decade.